Il Divo (2008)
Region 2 DVD Video Review
31-08-2009 18:00  |  3204 views   |   Noel Megahey   |   My Other Content
 
Following The Consequences of Love and The Family Friend, Paolo Sorrentino’s fascination for eccentric characters in positions of power and their abuse of it, almost inevitably turns to politics, and in Italian politics there is clearly a wealth of interesting figures to choose from. Avoiding the more obvious choice of Silvio Berlusconi – already the subject of Nanni Moretti’s Il CaimanoIl Divo brings to the screen the perhaps less internationally prominent figure of Giulio Andreotti, whose presence and influence on the scene of Italian politics as the head of the Christian Democrat party nonetheless encompasses no less than seven terms of government.


A nondescript individual, lacking charisma, fond of making epigrammatic remarks in a low dull monotone, Andreotti as depicted by Tony Servillo in Sorrentino’s film is nonetheless an astute politician, knowing who to make alliances with and knowing how to keep distance between those alliances when scandals erupt. As part of the Andreotti faction of the Christian Democrats he can count on influential figures from a wide range of sectors, like Paolo Cirino Pomicino ‘The Minister’, Franco Evangelisti ‘The Lemon’, Guiseppe Ciarrapico ‘Il Ciarra’, Vittorio Sbardella ‘The Shark’ and Cardinal Fiorenzo Angelini ‘His Healthiness’ among his associates. Andreotti is a survivor. Soldering on regardlessly while others come and go, as time passes by, as scandals erupt and governments fall, as other bankers and politicians die or are assassinated, Senator Andreotti emerges unscathed from it all, and puts himself forward for election as President of the Republic. But talk of his involvement with the Mafia continues to circulate, and as important trials are about to take place, Andreotti is called to testify before a judicial committee.

I have a great deal of sympathy for anyone reading the above paragraph and wondering what possible interest there could be in making a film on Italian politics, or more relevantly, what interest anyone living outside Italy could have in watching a film about an obscure Italian statesman. Well, there’s only one reason anyone would be really interested and that is because it’s a film by Paolo Sorrentino, and it’s filmed in exactly the highly-stylised manner you would expect of the director of The Consequences of Love and The Family Friend. Great news if you’re a fan of the director’s grotesque caricatures, his overblown camera movements, exaggerated angles and surreal arrangements – an absolute nightmare for anyone with an aversion not only to his laboured visual style, but also to anything to do with screen depictions of Italian politics.


The listing of all the members of the Andreotti faction in the second paragraph as if they might mean something is not unintentional – it’s there to provides a clue as to how Sorrentino approaches his subject. Each of these characters, none of whom you will ever have heard of before, are introduced with sweeping slow-motion camera shots, eye-catching angles and freeze-frames, with bold titles leaping across the screen as special effects as if they were characters from Reservoir Dogs. The allusion is no doubt intentional, but it feels highly inappropriate. I guess it’s what passes for satire with Sorrentino, and I’ve no doubt those in the know will find it highly amusing, but for those outside, and those moreover not best disposed to the director’s style, it’s just extremely irritating and meaningless.

Caricature is however the name of the game, the film’s quirkiness relying heavily on Tony Servillo’s mannered impersonation of Andreotti, shuffling along like nothing so much as Max Schreck’s Nosferatu. This mind-numbingly tedious journey through Italian politics then consists of an endless parade of immaculately dressed, well-groomed old men in expensive suits pumping up each other’s egos, cutting each other’s throats or stabbing each other in the back when the Mafia aren’t doing it for them, while Andreotti sits enigmatically at the centre of the storm, worrying about how Tedex features in the pharmaceutical codex ...whatever that is. (That’s rhetorical, by the way – I’m not really interested). Sorrentino attempts to sex-up this seemingly endless catalogue of “important” names through his “impressive” visual mannerisms and surreal tableaux vivants that have no rhyme or reason, peppering the “plot” with snappy explosions and assassinations, all scored to Sibelius and a distracting – though occasionally welcomingly diverting – loud pop score. If the intention of II Divo is to leave you feeling nauseated at what you are viewing and provoke a deep migraine, then I guess you could say it succeeds.

DVD


Il Divo is released in the UK by Artificial Eye. The DVD is in PAL format, and is encoded for Region 2.

Video
Regardless of the vacuity of the imagery, it’s hard to fault the quality of the image presented on the DVD. Colour tones are superb, skin tones warm, contrasting with the coldness of the lighting and dark settings elsewhere. There is a fine grain which pleasingly takes away from the otherwise clinical look of the film and the arrangements. For the most part the progressively encoded image flows smoothly with no significant issues of macroblocking, blacks remaining stable and solid and showing reasonably good shadow detail. Very rarely some slight flicker and breaking of fine lines can be detected on camera pans, but this is a minor issue that doesn’t alter the fact that this is a fine transfer. The aspect ratio, from my measurements, appears to be 2.30:1, and the transfer is of course anamorphically enhanced.


Audio
Dolby Digital 2.0 and Dolby Digital 5.1 audio tracks are included. The soundtrack is meant to impress just as much as the visuals, with punchy explosions and a pounding pop score, and these all come across well, but most effectively evidently in the surround mix.

Subtitles
English subtitles are provided in a clear white font and are optional.

Extras
The film is well supported with a strong selection of extra features that include a Making Of (31:07), a Special Effects Featurette (7:15), Deleted Scenes (11:54), Interview with Paolo Sorrentino 1 (12:11), Interview with Paolo Sorrentino 2 (16:51) and the film’s Trailer (1:22). A quick scan through them reveals that there is some repetition of information, but they will all certainly be of interest to anyone who enjoys the film, particularly the interviews with the director where he talks about making a film about an important living public figure and the difficulty this presents in terms of getting investment. Sorrentino speculates on the reasons for the failure of the Italian media to engage with the themes raised by the film, but isn't really surprised at the tactful silence from critics and politicians.


Overall
I don’t know what I was thinking when I volunteered to review Il Divo. I’ve found Paolo Sorrentino’s previous films so mannered and irritating as to be virtually unwatchable, yet they are all highly praised by international film critics. Il Divo then at least is no exception. If you’ve enjoyed the director’s previous films, then you’ll get on well with this bold flight through the murky complexity of Italian politics that is a natural extension of his earlier work, taking it to even greater lengths. For those who find the style and content of Sorrentino’s work to be empty and meaningless, I’d suggest you don’t make the same mistake I made and avoid Il Divo altogether. If you haven’t seen a Sorrentino film before, this probably isn’t the best place to start. Il Divo however is given a superb transfer by Artificial Eye and is supported with a fine selection of extra features.
Please help support The Digital Fix by purchasing this title or any others through our affiliate links...

101 CD
£3.99
dvd.co.uk
£3.99
Blah DVD
£3.99
Base.com
£3.99


Recommend this article to your friends by clicking the link below.

By liking our page you'll get updates posted directly to your news feed so you never miss a thing!


You can also follow us on Twitter at these accounts:


#1 Posted: 31-08-2009 18:42
tonyleung
Member
Posts: 854

1 out of 10! Fine you didn't like it but 1 out of 10? That would put it against the worst films ever made and this so isn't.

I'd give it 6 out of 10 myself, hard work in places but overall still very good.

Quote this post
#2 Posted: 31-08-2009 21:26
Bunta Sugawara
Member
Posts: 18
1/10? If the "one reason anyone would be really interested" in a film about Italian politics is because Paulo Sorrentino made it, ergo it would be impossible for a non-Italian to find interest in, say, the filmography of Francesco Rosi, Investigation of a Citizen above Suspicion, or The Conformist?

"Mind-numbingly tedious"? But...but.. you gave the Bill Douglas trilogy 10/10!!

I'd give it a 9/10
Quote this post
#3 Posted: 31-08-2009 21:56
Michael Brooke
Member
Posts: 650
Well, in Noel's defence, he admitted that he hated Sorrentino's work anyway and is totally uninterested in the film's subject (so uninterested, in fact, that he can describe one of the most prominent European politicians of the last few decades as "obscure" with a straight face), so it's clear that the review's going to be pretty worthless for anyone seeking an insight into the film.

But what baffles me is that Noel was so utterly disengaged from the film that he couldn't find anything of interest in it. Really? Given the many allegations raised by the film, surely the mere fact that Andreotti is still alive creates a near-constant tension from the start, especially when Sorrentino has him cheekily announcing on screen that he's never sued anyone for defamation. Certainly, as the film edged closer and closer to the tangentopoli investigations of the early 1990s I was wondering just how far Sorrentino would dare push this. (As it turned out, the most damning allegation is told in flashback through the eyes of a possibly unreliable witness, a neat bit of arse-covering). And if you're not interested in that... well, why are you bothering to watch a film about Andreotti in the first place?

Hopefully those prepared to approach the film with a slightly more open mind will find it as exhilarating as I did - and I still haven't seen a decent copy yet. So in this respect the review is genuinely useful, as it at least confirms that the DVD is clearly worth buying.

Interestingly, this marks the second creatively outstanding portrait of a prominent 1980s/90s European politician - Robert Guediguian's more sedate but often equally sly portrait of François Mitterrand, The Last Mitterrand, would make a great double bill partner.
Quote this post
#4 Posted: 01-09-2009 11:29
DeBellio (tn)
Member
Posts: 1
1 out of 10 is such a ridiculous rating for such a thematically strong and visually stunning film that i will find it difficult to rely on this reveiwers rating system ever again. The recent revelations of signor Berlusconi's misdemeanors during his time in power make this film even more relevant and its a shame that current British film makers don't seem to have the courage to make something similar, especially with the allegations towards the Blair government. I'd love to see a objective film about the David Kelly affair and the involvement of Britain in Afghanistan, instead we make do with portrayals of the Prime Minister in such insightful films as 'The Queen'.
Quote this post
#5 Posted: 01-09-2009 16:45
GreatDane
Member
Posts: 87

Yes, 1 out of 10 is a ridiculous rating, and totally amateurish.  On the other hand, I gave The Mist 1 out of 10. Worst movie I have ever seen in a decade, which was also the lowest rating I have ever given a movie.  Although, I respect Noel Megahey thoughts I totally disagree with him.  Noel and I are just so far apart as possible regarding movie taste. 

However, I loved Sorrentino's previous The Consequences of Love and The Family Friend.  This means I´ll give Il Divo 10 out of 10

Quote this post
#6 Posted: 06-09-2009 10:09
Noel M
Contributor
Posts: 485
And if you're not interested in that... well, why are you bothering to watch a film about Andreotti in the first place?

What an odd question, Michael. Obviously, I hoped I might learn something about the subject. I don't know about you, but I don't just stick to subjects or films that I already know I'm going to like when watching or reviewing movies. It was expecting depth or insightful characterisation from a Sorrentino film however that was clearly my mistake here.

As far as I'm concerned, it's a worthless and ridiculous film that is full of caricature and flashy camera angles, so I don't see what the problem is here. A 1/10 unambiguously reflects my view on the film. To even mention Il Divo in the same sentence as The Conformist, as one person commented here, is laughable. As the closing paragraph indicates however, other people more predisposed towards Sorrentino or the subject will get more out of it than I did.

And you're all welcome to your own opinion, whereas clearly some people think I'm not and that I really should agree with them. I don't understand that.
Quote this post
#7 Posted: 24-11-2009 23:55
Phil Q
Member
Posts: 1817
Quote:
Well, there’s only one reason anyone would be really interested and that is because it’s a film by Paolo Sorrentino, and it’s filmed in exactly the highly-stylised manner you would expect of the director of The Consequences of Love and The Family Friend. Great news if you’re a fan of the director’s grotesque caricatures, his overblown camera movements, exaggerated angles and surreal arrangements – an absolute nightmare for anyone with an aversion not only to his laboured visual style, but also to anything to do with screen depictions of Italian politics.


I'm extremely late to this party, so there's really no point commenting, however..... I am a fan of Sorrentino's previous films, and expected to like Il Divo. But I found it almost unwatchable, so much so that I actually gave up before the end (I can't even remember the last time I did that).

Maybe it requires some knowledge or understanding of Italian politics - I have neither - but I found it completely incomprehensible. And it wasn't interesting enough to make me want to learn more.

You're right about the Nosferatu resemblance, too.
Quote this post
#8 Posted: 25-11-2009 09:44
Michael Brooke
Member
Posts: 650
I think it almost certainly does need some background knowledge - mine's pretty sketchy, but I have at least read Tobias Jones' 'The Dark Heart of Italy', which provides a huge amount of extremely relevant context. I also have vivid memories of the 'tangentopoli' investigations of the early 1990s - an article in a British newspaper at the time said that what was happening in Italy was the equivalent of something like all major party leaders and over 500 MPs being investigated on serious corruption charges (and this is Italian corruption, which is on a whole 'nother plane from the British variety - we should actually be proud of the fact that Neil Hamilton is regarded as the worst of the worst, because his "crimes" would barely register in many other countries).

So when I say I found 'Il Divo' completely riveting, which I did (in fact, it only just missed out on my Sight & Sound 2009 top five, and might well have been included if I hadn't finally caught up with'The Hurt Locker' the night before the deadline), I suspect even with my relatively limited knowledge I was able to make rather more connections than a complete neophyte would have done. And of course an Italian audience would have picked up on a whole encylopaedia of nuances - and I strongly suspect, as with Andrzej Wajda's 'Katyn', that the film was primarily aimed at the director's compatriots.
Quote this post
#9 Posted: 26-11-2009 00:32
Phil Q
Member
Posts: 1817
Thanks Michael. At least that makes me feel slightly less of an idiot!
Quote this post


Comment on this content - sign up for a Digital Fix login, or sign in now
Username:
Password:
Remember:
Register now!