Assault On Precinct 13 (1976)
Region 2 DVD Video Review
17-01-2005 22:00  |  10329 views   |   Mike Sutton   |   My Other Content   |   Other content for "Assault on Precinct 13"
 
Assault On Precinct 13 is one of the best low-budget action movies ever made and a model of good B-Movie filmmaking. It’s short, lean and agonisingly suspenseful, paying homage to its influences without ripping them off wholesale. Although it was only the second film directed by John Carpenter, it remains one of his most effective and it stands out as the movie where he began collecting together a reliable team of collaborators who stayed with him for the next few years, the period during which he made most of his classic films. There’s nothing particularly original about it and in some respects it does seem a little dated but when a film is delivered with as much style and pace as this, the flaws are very easy to overlook.

After an assault on some of their members by police, a Californian gang swear a blood oath to avenge the deaths of their brothers. When a further gang member is killed by the father of a girl who has been cold-bloodedly shot, the thugs discover that he is being held at an obsolete police station which is being supervised for the night by Lt. Bishop (Stoker). However, they don’t realise that the station is also housing Wilson (Joston), a convicted killer on his way to death row, and two other dangerous prisoners. As the gangs lay siege to the station, Bishop and the station receptionist Leigh (Zimmer) discover that they must join forces with Wilson if they are to have any hope of surviving the night.

It’s astonishing, in retrospect, how effective this film remains, despite certain facets which date it. There are, of course, no computers or mobile phones, both of which would intrinsically change the plotting, and the gang members would almost certainly be using automatic weapons were it made today – it will be interesting to see how the upcoming remake incorporates these changes in society. It’s also been said that John Carpenter’s synthesiser score is hopelessly dated and unintentionally comic – this is something I fiercely dispute. It’s as effective now as it was at the time and if you really can’t watch a film without giggling at the use of a primitive synthesiser then you shouldn’t be watching movies in the first place since you clearly can’t suspend your disbelief. So let’s instead look at the incredible achievement of the film. It cost $100,000 and not a frame of film is wasted. It’s as pared-down a suspense film as you could wish for with every element carefully placed to add to the development of the narrative or the characters. Carpenter’s use of real locations is masterful – the use of Venice Police Station as a location and the surrounding district of California, some kind of urban wasteland. The sense of sun-drenched day turning into seemingly endless night is beautifully evoked – the skies are often gorgeous – and this is something which links a number of Carpenter films, ranging from Halloween to Prince of Darkness. Indeed, the latter film is almost a remake of Assault on Precinct 13 with added supernatural bunkum. Also well in evidence is Carpenter’s ability to use the possibilities of the Panavision frame. This was his first film in 2.35:1 and his exploration of the far sides of the frame is one of the things which makes him a contemporary director as opposed to the directors who influenced him, most of whom hated having to use anything wider than 1.85:1 – and Ford and Hawks weren’t overly keen on anything wider than Academy ratio.

The key influence behind the film is Howard Hawks’ Rio Bravo. John Carpenter has gone on record as saying that Hawks is his favourite director and in this film he certainly shows signs of having learned some valuable lessons from the older filmmaker. His pacing is brisk without being confusing and he is careful to include minor diversions which enhance the piece without being absolutely essential. The conversation in the car between the father and daughter, for example. Since they are a plot mechanism to get the gangs to lay siege to the precinct, we don’t necessarily need to know why anything much about them or why they’re going into the dangerous Anderson district but the conversation which explains this both gives them a reason to be there and allows the characters to display some distinctive humour and a credible relationship. The same goes for the conversation in the bus between Stalker and Wilson when the latter has a great line; “Now, days for me are just like women. Each one of em is so goddamn precious And they always end up leaving you.” Inn some respects, Wilson is the most philosophical character in the film and his constant refrain of “Got a smoke?” makes him quirky and likeable – quite a feat considering he’s a convicted killer and something which obviously amused Carpenter.

This attention to character is something which denotes all of Carpenter’s best work and even his least interesting films are often good in this respect – the oddball group of vampire hunters led by James Woods in Vampires for example. Again, this is a lesson learned from Howard Hawks and the three leading characters in the film are very much in the Hawksian tradition. Wilson, witty and reflective, is far from the usual stereotype of a killer bound for death row and becomes something of an anti-hero. Leigh, the secretary – presumably named in tribute to the screenwriter of The Big Sleep, El Dorado and Rio Lobo, Leigh Brackett – is a classic Hawksian woman, resourceful and fiercely independent. Lt. Bishop is humourous, wry, honourable and tough – not at all unlike a Wayne hero in one of Hawks’ westerns (among whom John T. Chance stands out, and Carpenter’s little tribute to this character is the editor credit).

Of course, Bishop is also black, and the fact that this is rarely an issue, with the exception of a joke he makes when Leigh offers him coffee, reminds the viewer of Night Of The Living Dead. Nor is this the only reminder, since the sequences in which the scarily numerous and anonymous thugs attempt to storm the police station through the doors and windows are highly endebted to the similar sequences in Romero’s film. There’s a certain amount of Hitchcock’s The Birds in these scenes too. You’ll also spot more than a touch of Straw Dogs, particularly in the plot line of a collection of brutal thugs wanting to get at a man who they perceive to owe them his life. I also have to point out the presence of Henry Brandon as the desk sergeant - Brandon played Scar in another of Carpenter's favourite films, The Searchers.

Yet in retrospect, the film seems all of a piece and very much the original work of a director who knows exactly what he’s doing. Carpenter’s sense of pace (I disagree with his retrospective assessment that the film is too slow), his kinetic action scenes and his careful building of tension are all present here – along with some of his familiar collaborators including Tommy Wallace and Debra Hill - and these are the things which made his name in his next film, the extraordinary Halloween. If Assault on Precinct 13 is somehow less impressive than that later film, it’s still a superb thriller and the remake will have to go a long way to convince me that another version was required in the first place. Incidentally, as all fans of the film will know, the assault in question is actually on Precinct 9, Division 13 – but I think we can all agree that Assault on Precinct 13 is a much better title.

The Disc

Back in 2000, Universal issued Assault On Precinct 13 on a disc which contained a very poor transfer in the wrong aspect ratio. Since then, a special edition has been released in the USA by Image. Now, we have a new R2 disc from Contender which, while advertised as a special edition, only contains the film, a trailer and a very small photo gallery. Luckily, the transfer is of a very high standard and this compensates somewhat for the paucity of extras.

The film is presented in its correct Panavision ratio of 2.35:1 and has been anamorphically enhanced. It’s an excellent picture, somewhat better than that on the R1 Image disc with less artifacting and more satisfying colours. The blacks are suitably deep and the colours are well defined. There is a very small amount of edge enhancement in occasional scenes and very small instances of artifacting, but overall the picture quality is exemplary.

The soundtrack is a Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono transfer of the original mono track. It’s a strong soundtrack, coping well with the limitations of the low-budget material and showcasing Carpenter’s pounding soundtrack. Dialogue is crisp and clear throughout.

The original theatrical trailer is included, looking a lot better than it does on the R1 Image disc. We also get a very small photo gallery in which the pictures are so small it’s sometimes hard to make out what they’re showing.

The film is divided into 16 chapter stops and there are, shamefully, no subtitles. This is particularly regrettable because the R1 edition doesn’t have any subtitles either.

Assault On Precinct 13 is a tough, exciting film which makes a great deal out of not very much. It’s one of the best exploitation movies ever made and deserves a wide audience. This DVD is impressive in terms of its transfer but the lack of extras makes the ‘Special Edition’ claim somewhat hard to justify.


Recommend this article to your friends by clicking the link below.

By liking our page you'll get updates posted directly to your news feed so you never miss a thing!


You can also follow us on Twitter at these accounts:


#1 Posted: 17-01-2005 22:47
Darth_Fisto
Account Disabled
Posts: 162
"It’s also been said that John Carpenter’s synthesiser score is hopelessly dated... if you really can’t watch a film without giggling at the use of a primitive synthesiser then you shouldn’t be watching movies in the first place since you clearly can’t suspend your disbelief."

Surely most people giggle because it reminds them of the time it was made? Synth scores are also laughable now because they are still used in some films (Undead used them quite well, but it was still funny).

I'm not a massive fan of Carpenter, but I really like The Thing and Halloween, think Big Trouble in Little China is a hell of a lot of fun... and I really like this film. I agree with pretty much everything you said, and shall be waiting for the DVD to dip in price :D

Good review
Quote this post
#2 Posted: 17-01-2005 22:53
Mike Sutton
Contributor
Posts: 611
I was hoping someone would rise to that one ;) Good response as well.

Thanks for the comment.
Quote this post
#3 Posted: 18-01-2005 02:10
Anorakus
Member
Posts: 32
Wasn't Halloween Carpenter's first film shot in Panavision?

A.
Quote this post
#4 Posted: 18-01-2005 07:59
Mike Sutton
Contributor
Posts: 611
No. "Assault" predates "Halloween" by 2 years.
Quote this post
#5 Posted: 18-01-2005 08:11
stigdu
Horror fan
Posts: 13
Having never owned the film, I was awaiting a comparison between the new R1 and R2 editions. It looks like the R2 wins out on picture quality, so I'll go for that (although I would have loved the commentary track from the R1 to have been present). Great review, Mike.
Quote this post
#6 Posted: 18-01-2005 12:39
djnock
Member
Posts: 203
I totally adore this movie. It's got to be my favourite film in Carpenter's filmography - it's a fine study in tension and mood; all the better since it lacks the bells and whistles that many action films feel the need to include (I, for one, love the synth score - it sticks in your head for days, and I even bought the soundtrack...how sad am I?)

So yes, big, big fan of this movie, and you nailed my feelings completely Mike. Couldn't have reviewed it better. Of course, I advise everyone to get the R1 copy - this is very disappointing.

Speaking of disappointment, I got the chance to see the remake early, and while it paled next to Carpenter's classic, I was pleasantly surprised. It's dark and very violent, yet it lacks the simple strokes of JC's work. It also misses the truly horrifying ice cream truck sequence. Damn Hollywood!!

D.J.
------
DVD Times Contributor
Quote this post
#7 Posted: 18-01-2005 18:25
ty7du
Wanker of the 1st Degree
Posts: 210
I love the score in this film. Simple and effective. Darth_Fisto, funny that you mention other Carpenter films, since the scores used in those films are also synth.

And when the main theme comes again at the end, it makes the moment all the more cool.

The R1 edition has an isolated music track. Even the ice-cream van jingle is on the track!

Just to let you know, an Icelandic rapper used the main theme in his song.

I'm just wondering here, for comparison of the R1 Image edition (NEW SPECIAL EDITION).

Mike, are there cigarette burn marks in the film?

And I just can't remember, but I think it was in the jail cell at the precinct, where there was a horrible scratch marks all over the film?

Thanks.
Quote this post
#8 Posted: 18-01-2005 19:15
djnock
Member
Posts: 203
are there cigarette burn marks in the film?

And I just can't remember, but I think it was in the jail cell at the precinct, where there was a horrible scratch marks all over the film?


That was a fault during filming I think, or when the film was being edited in post.

I think you're referring to the scene where Napoleon fights a gang member in his cell, before retreating. If so, the problem was with the original print.

I don't think there was anything Image could do to clear up the picture in that scene. Don't know about the new disc. Is the scene still grainy and scratched Mike?

D.J.
------
DVD Times Contributor
Quote this post
#9 Posted: 18-01-2005 19:48
JimdiGriz
Member
Posts: 370
John Carpenter's creepy synth tracks really add to his films..imagine The Thing, Assault, The Fog, Escape from New York without them - they wouldn't be the same. Anyone laughing at the soundtracks wouldn't like the films anyway I imagine, they'd be happier watching the likes of Scream etc etc
Quote this post
#10 Posted: 18-01-2005 20:07
stigdu
Horror fan
Posts: 13
Is the R2 really much better than the R1 in terms of picture quality? Also, I notice it only has stereo sound when compared to the R1's 5.1 surround. Which region would you say had the better sound?

And JimdiGriz - are you Jason from Billericay??
Quote this post
#11 Posted: 18-01-2005 22:59
Mike Sutton
Contributor
Posts: 611
Well the film was made in wonderful mono so I don't give a damn about 5.1, personally. If it's not got the original soundtrack as an option, it's worthless (in the opinion of this writer. If you like remixes then good luck to you). The R1 edition is DD 2.0 Mono by the way, like the R2.

In my opinion, there is a significant improvement in the picture quality on the R2 disc. I haven't got a DVD-ROM so I can't do screenshots but the difference in the opening scene was immediately evident.
Quote this post
#12 Posted: 18-01-2005 23:28
djnock
Member
Posts: 203
In my opinion, there is a significant improvement in the picture quality on the R2 disc. I haven't got a DVD-ROM so I can't do screenshots but the difference in the opening scene was immediately evident.

You think I should double-dip then Mike?

I know it's up to me really, but is the quality worth the upgrade?

D.J.
------
DVD Times Contributor
Quote this post
#13 Posted: 19-01-2005 08:06
Mike Sutton
Contributor
Posts: 611
To be honest, D.J., no. It's a jump from a good picture to a very good picture in my opinion - but we're not talking a totally different experience as with, for example, the old and new editions of "Top Gun". Anyone who likes the film and hasn't got it would still be better getting the R1 because of the special features. This new R2 is overpriced for what we get.

Hope this is clear. I try to avoid getting too deeply into comparisons because there's a large element of subjectivity.
Quote this post
#14 Posted: 19-01-2005 08:07
stigdu
Horror fan
Posts: 13
Cheers Mike, that's defintely swung it for me. I don't care much for these faux-5.1 mixes anyhoo. R2 it is, then.
Quote this post
#15 Posted: 19-01-2005 09:02
Patrick Bateman
Member
Posts: 371
I'd always prefer mono soundtracks to be formatted to 5.1. Carpenter's score for this film ROCKS:eek:
------
'It's an epic meditation on intangibility'
Quote this post
#16 Posted: 19-01-2005 11:05
Mike Sutton
Contributor
Posts: 611
I don't mind remixes as long as the original soundtrack is included as well.
Quote this post
#17 Posted: 19-01-2005 16:32
ty7du
Wanker of the 1st Degree
Posts: 210
I don't think they could make it sound great in 5.1. Well, paging THX.

If anything, even a stereo remix would be more than adequate for this movie.

But I still like the fact you get a little thump from the subwoofer from the bass in the music score.
Quote this post
#18 Posted: 19-01-2005 16:39
ty7du
Wanker of the 1st Degree
Posts: 210
And funny, I bought this movie on VHS not long ago I got the R1 DVD. And the difference was staggering, not to mention to be able to see it in widescreen. The VHS tape was unwatchable after seeing the DVD. On the VHS there was this terrible bloom of white from the text used in the film. And the whole thing was just murky as hell.

I would only double-dip if the R2 had the same extras, because they are great. If anything, I would want to hear the techno remix of the main theme. It became a hit at the time of the release. On the R1 DVD they had photos of various things connected to the film, and there was this cover of a vinyl record.

If they only could have sneaked that in somehow...as an easter egg or something.
Quote this post
#19 Posted: 20-01-2005 14:31
JimdiGriz
Member
Posts: 370
stigdu...no I'm not Jason from Billericay!
Quote this post
#20 Posted: 22-01-2005 20:38
stuartbannerman
Member
Posts: 305
Id opt for the Region1 .....as any chance to listen to John Carpenter on a commentery is worth it in my book!!!
Quote this post
#21 Posted: 28-01-2005 22:21
in2deep
Member
Posts: 15
Interesting comments about the remake - typical of Hollywood to miss out key parts of the story because of American society's political correctness! I've always liked the original for its simplicity of story, and the way that every scene means something. The remake will have a lot to live up to - perhaps they should have not used the original title!
Quote this post


Comment on this content - sign up for a Digital Fix login, or sign in now
Username:
Password:
Remember:
Register now!